Appendixes. Appendix I. Khing Kang King
p. 247
Appendixes.
Appendix I.
Khing Kng King, Or 'The Classic Of Purity 1.'
So I must translate the title of this brochure, as it appears in the 'Collection of the Most Important Treatises of the Toist Fathers' (vol. xxxix, p. xvii), in which alone I have had an opportunity of perusing and studying the Text. The name, as given by Wylie (Notes, p. 178), Balfour (Toist Texts.), and Faber (China Review, vol. xiii, p. 246), is Khing King King 2, and signifies 'The Classic of Purity and Rest.' The difference is in the second character, but both Khing Kng and Khing King are well-known combinations in Toist writings; and it will be seen, as the translation of the Text is pursued, that neither of them is unsuitable as the title of the little Book.
It is, as Dr. Faber says, one of the 'mystical canons' of Toism; but the mysticism of Toism is of a nature peculiar to itself, and different from any mental exercises which have been called by that name in connexion with Christianity or Mohammedanism. It is more vague and shadowy than any theosophy or Sfism, just as the idea of the To differs from the apprehension of a personal God, however uncertain and indefinite that apprehension may be. Mr. Wylie says the work 'treats under very moderate limits of the subjection of the mental faculties.' This indeed is the consummation to which it conducts the student; a
p. 248
condition corresponding to the nothingness which Lo-dze contended for as antecedent to all positive existence, and out of which he said that all existing being came, though he does not indicate how.
I give to the Treatise the first place among our appendixes here because of the early origin ascribed to it. It is attributed to Ko Yan (or Hsan) 1, a Toist of the W dynasty (a.d. 222-277), who is fabled to have attained to the state of an Immortal, and is generally so denominated 2. He is represented as a worker of miracles; as addicted to intemperance, and very eccentric in his ways. When shipwrecked on one occasion, he emerged from beneath the water with his clothes unwet, and walked freely on its surface. Finally he ascended to the sky in bright day 3. All these accounts may safely be put down as the figments of a later time.
It will be seen that the Text ascribes the work to Lo-dze himself, and I find it impossible to accept the account of its origin which is assigned by L Hs-yeh to Ko Hsan. As quoted by L in the first of some notes subjoined to his Commentary, Ko is made to say, 'When I obtained the true To, I had recited this King ten thousand times. It is what the Spirits of heaven practise, and had not been communicated to scholars of this lower world. I got it from the Divine Ruler of the eastern Hwa; he received it from the Divine Ruler of the Golden Gate; he received it from the Royal-mother of the West. In all these cases it was transmitted from mouth to mouth, and was not committed to writing. I now, while I am in the world, have written it out in a book. Scholars of the highest order, understanding it, ascend and become officials of Heaven; those of the middle order, cultivating it, are ranked among the Immortals of the Southern Palace; those of the lowest order, possessing it, get long years of life in the world, roam
p. 249
through the Three Regions 1a, and (finally) ascend to, and enter, the Golden Gate.'
This quotation would seem to be taken from the preface to our little classic by Ho Hsan. If there were indeed such a preface during the time of the W dynasty, the corruption of the old Toism must have been rapid. The Hs Wang-m, or Royal-mother of the West, is mentioned once in Kwang-dze (Bk. VI, par. 7); but no 'Divine Ruler' disfigures his pages. Every reader must feel that in the Classic of Purity he has got into a different region of thought from that which he has traversed in the To Teh King and in the writings of Kwang-dze.
With these remarks I now proceed to the translation and explanation of the text of our King.
"Ch. 1. 1. Lo the Master 1 said, The Great 2 To has no bodily form, but It produced and nourishes heaven and earth 3. The Great To has no passions 4, but It causes the sun and moon to revolve as they do.
The Great 2 To has no name 5, but It effects the growth and maintenance of all things 3.
I do not know its name, but I make an effort, and call It the To 6.
p. 250
2. Now, the To (shows itself in two forms); the Pure and the Turbid, and has (the two conditions of) Motion and Rest 1. Heaven is pure and earth is turbid; heaven moves and earth is at rest. The masculine is pure and the feminine is turbid; the masculine moves and the feminine is still 2. The radical (Purity) descended, and the (turbid) issue flowed abroad; and thus all things were produced 1.
The pure is the source of the turbid, and motion is the foundation of rest.
If man could always be pure and still, heaven and earth would both revert (to non-existence) 3.
p. 251
3. Now the spirit of man loves Purity, but his mind 1 disturbs it. The mind of man loves stillness, but his desires draw it away 1. If he could always send his desires away, his mind would of itself become still. Let his mind be made clean, and his spirit will of itself become pure.
As a matter of course the six desires 2 will not arise, and the three poisons 3 will be taken away and disappear.
4. The reason why men are not able to attain to this, is because their minds have not been cleansed, and their desires have not been sent away.
p. 252
If one is able to send the desires away, when he then looks in at his mind, it is no longer his; when he looks out at his body, it is no longer his; and when he looks farther off at external things, they are things which he has nothing to do with.
When he understands these three things, there will appear to him only vacancy. This contemplation of vacancy will awaken the idea of vacuity. Without such vacuity there is no vacancy.
The idea of vacuous space having vanished, that of nothingness itself also disappears; and when the idea of nothingness has disappeared, there ensues serenely the condition of constant stillness. 1
5. In that condition of rest independently of place how can any desire arise? And when no desire any longer arises, there is the True stillness and rest.
That True (stillness) becomes (a) constant quality, and responds to external things (without error); yea, that True and Constant quality holds possession of the nature.
In such constant response and constant stillness there is the constant Purity and Rest.
He who has this absolute Purity enters gradually into the (inspiration of the) True To. And
p. 253
having entered thereinto, he is styled Possessor of the To.
Although he is styled Possessor of the To, in reality he does not think that he has become possessed of anything. It is as accomplishing the transformation of all living things, that he is styled Possessor of the To.
He who is able to understand this may transmit to others the Sacred To. 5 1
2. 1. Lo the Master said, Scholars of the highest class do not strive (for anything); those of the lowest class are fond of striving 1. Those who possess in the highest degree the attributes (of the To) do not show them; those who possess them in a low degree hold them fast (and display them) 2. Those who so hold them fast and display them are not styled (Possessors of) the To and Its attributes 2.
2. The reason why all men do not obtain the True To is because their minds are perverted. Their minds being perverted, their spirits become perturbed. Their minds being perturbed, they are attracted towards external things. Being attracted towards external things, they begin to seek for them greedily. This greedy quest leads to perplexities and annoyances; and these again result in disordered
p. 254
thoughts, which cause anxiety and trouble to both body and mind. The parties then meet with foul disgraces, flow wildly on through the phases of life and death, are liable constantly to sink in the sea of bitterness, and for ever lose the True To.
3. The True and Abiding To! They who understand it naturally obtain it. And they who come to understand. the To abide in Purity and Stillness. 1
Footnotes
247:1
.
247:2
.
248:1
or
.
248:2
.
248:3 See the Accounts of Ko in the Biographical Dictionary of Hsio Kih-han (1793), and Wang Kh's supplement to the great work of M Twan-lin, ch. 242.
249:1a 'The three regions (
)' here can hardly be the trilokya of the Buddhists, the ethical categories of desire, form, and formlessness. They are more akin to the Brahmanic bhuvanatraya, the physical or cosmological categories of bhr or earth, bhuvah or heaven, and svar or atmosphere.
249:1 The name here is Lo Kn (
). I have stated (vol. xxxix, p. 40) that, with the addition of Thi Shang, this is the common designation of Lo-dze as the Father of Toism and deifying him, and that it originated probably in the Thang dynasty. It might seem to be used simply here by Ko Hsan with the same high application; and since in his preface he refers to different 'Divine Rulers,' it may be contended that we ought to translate Lo Kn by 'Lo the Ruler.' But I am unwilling to think that the deification of Lo-dze p. 250 had taken place so early. The earliest occurrence of the combination Lo Kn which has attracted my notice is in the history of Khung Yung, a descendant of Confucius in the twentieth generation,--the same who is celebrated in the San Dze King, for his fraternal deference at the age of four, and who met with a violent death in A.d. 208. While still only a boy, wishing to obtain an interview with a representative of the Lo family, he sent in this message to him, 'My honoured predecessor and the honoured Lo, the predecessor of your Li family, equally virtuous and righteous, were friends and teachers of each other.' The epithet Kn is equally applied to Confucius and Lo-dze, and the combination Lo Kn implies no exaltation of the latter above the other.
249:2 See To Teh King, chaps. 18, 25, 53.
249:3 T. T. K., chaps. 1, 51, et al.
249:4 See Kwang-dze, Bk. II, par. 2. 'Passions,' that is, feelings, affections; as in the first of the thirty-nine Articles.
249:5 T. T. K., chaps. 1, 25, 32, 51.
249:6 T. T. K., ch. 25.
250:1 This paragraph is intended to set forth 'the production of all things;' but it does so in a way that is hardly intelligible. Comparing what is said here with the utterances in the former paragraph, To would seem to be used in two p. 251 senses; first as an Immaterial Power or Force, and next as the Material Substance, out of which all things come. Li Hs-yeh says that in the first member of par. 1 we have 'the Unlimited (or Infinite) producing the Grand (or Primal) Finite.' On the To in par. 2 he says nothing. The fact is that the subject of creation in the deepest sense of the name is too high for the human mind.
250:2 Compare T. T. K., ch. 61.
250:3 I do not understand this, but I cannot translate the Text otherwise. Mr. Balfour has:--'If a man is able to remain pure and motionless, Heaven and Earth will both at once come and dwell in him.' L explains thus:--
. Compare T. T. K., ch. 16, and especially Ho-shang Kung's title to it,--
.
251:1 Toism thus recognises in man the spirit, the mind, and the body.
251:2 'The six desires' are those which have their inlets in the eyes, cars, nostrils, the tongue, the sense of touch, and the imagination. The two last are expressed in Chinese by shn, 'the body,' and , 'the idea, or thought.'
251:3 'The three poisons' are greed, anger, and stupidity;--see the Khang-hs Thesaurus, under
.
252:1 In this paragraph we have what Mr. Wylie calls 'the subjection of the mental faculties;' and I must confess myself unable to understand what it is. It is probably another way of describing the Toist trance which we find once and again in Kwang-dze, 'when the body becomes like a withered tree, and the mind like slaked lime' (Bk. II, par. 1, et al.). But such a sublimation of the being, as the characteristic of its serene stillness and rest, is to me inconceivable.
253:5 1 This is the consummation of the state of Purity. In explaining the former sentence of the fifth member, L Hs-yeh uses the characters of T. T. K., ch. 4,
, with some variation,--
.
253:1 Compare the T. T. K., ch. 41, 1.
253:2 Compare the T. T. K., ch. 38, 1.
254:1 Our brief Classic thus concludes, and our commentator Li thus sums up his remarks on it:--'The men who understand the To do so simply by means of the Absolute Purity, and the acquiring this Absolute Purity depends entirely on the Putting away of Desire, which is the urgent practical lesson of the Treatise.'
I quoted in my introductory remarks L's account of the origin of the Classic by its reputed author Ko Hsan. I will now conclude with the words which he subjoins from 'a True Man, Zo Hsan:'--'Students of the To, who keep this Classic in their hands and croon over its contents, will get good Spirits from the ten heavens to watch over and protect their bodies, after which their spirits will be preserved by the seal of jade, and their bodies refined by the elixir of gold. Both body and spirit will become exquisitely ethereal, and be in true union with the To!'
Of this 'True Man, Zo Hsan,' I have: not been able to ascertain anything. The Divine Ruler of the eastern Hwa, referred to on p. 248, is mentioned in the work of Wang Kh (ch. 241, p. 21b), but with no definite information about him. The author says his surname was Wang, but he knows neither his name nor when he lived.
Appendixes.
Appendix I.
Khing Kng King, Or 'The Classic Of Purity 1.'
So I must translate the title of this brochure, as it appears in the 'Collection of the Most Important Treatises of the Toist Fathers' (vol. xxxix, p. xvii), in which alone I have had an opportunity of perusing and studying the Text. The name, as given by Wylie (Notes, p. 178), Balfour (Toist Texts.), and Faber (China Review, vol. xiii, p. 246), is Khing King King 2, and signifies 'The Classic of Purity and Rest.' The difference is in the second character, but both Khing Kng and Khing King are well-known combinations in Toist writings; and it will be seen, as the translation of the Text is pursued, that neither of them is unsuitable as the title of the little Book.
It is, as Dr. Faber says, one of the 'mystical canons' of Toism; but the mysticism of Toism is of a nature peculiar to itself, and different from any mental exercises which have been called by that name in connexion with Christianity or Mohammedanism. It is more vague and shadowy than any theosophy or Sfism, just as the idea of the To differs from the apprehension of a personal God, however uncertain and indefinite that apprehension may be. Mr. Wylie says the work 'treats under very moderate limits of the subjection of the mental faculties.' This indeed is the consummation to which it conducts the student; a
p. 248
condition corresponding to the nothingness which Lo-dze contended for as antecedent to all positive existence, and out of which he said that all existing being came, though he does not indicate how.
I give to the Treatise the first place among our appendixes here because of the early origin ascribed to it. It is attributed to Ko Yan (or Hsan) 1, a Toist of the W dynasty (a.d. 222-277), who is fabled to have attained to the state of an Immortal, and is generally so denominated 2. He is represented as a worker of miracles; as addicted to intemperance, and very eccentric in his ways. When shipwrecked on one occasion, he emerged from beneath the water with his clothes unwet, and walked freely on its surface. Finally he ascended to the sky in bright day 3. All these accounts may safely be put down as the figments of a later time.
It will be seen that the Text ascribes the work to Lo-dze himself, and I find it impossible to accept the account of its origin which is assigned by L Hs-yeh to Ko Hsan. As quoted by L in the first of some notes subjoined to his Commentary, Ko is made to say, 'When I obtained the true To, I had recited this King ten thousand times. It is what the Spirits of heaven practise, and had not been communicated to scholars of this lower world. I got it from the Divine Ruler of the eastern Hwa; he received it from the Divine Ruler of the Golden Gate; he received it from the Royal-mother of the West. In all these cases it was transmitted from mouth to mouth, and was not committed to writing. I now, while I am in the world, have written it out in a book. Scholars of the highest order, understanding it, ascend and become officials of Heaven; those of the middle order, cultivating it, are ranked among the Immortals of the Southern Palace; those of the lowest order, possessing it, get long years of life in the world, roam
p. 249
through the Three Regions 1a, and (finally) ascend to, and enter, the Golden Gate.'
This quotation would seem to be taken from the preface to our little classic by Ho Hsan. If there were indeed such a preface during the time of the W dynasty, the corruption of the old Toism must have been rapid. The Hs Wang-m, or Royal-mother of the West, is mentioned once in Kwang-dze (Bk. VI, par. 7); but no 'Divine Ruler' disfigures his pages. Every reader must feel that in the Classic of Purity he has got into a different region of thought from that which he has traversed in the To Teh King and in the writings of Kwang-dze.
With these remarks I now proceed to the translation and explanation of the text of our King.
"Ch. 1. 1. Lo the Master 1 said, The Great 2 To has no bodily form, but It produced and nourishes heaven and earth 3. The Great To has no passions 4, but It causes the sun and moon to revolve as they do.
The Great 2 To has no name 5, but It effects the growth and maintenance of all things 3.
I do not know its name, but I make an effort, and call It the To 6.
p. 250
2. Now, the To (shows itself in two forms); the Pure and the Turbid, and has (the two conditions of) Motion and Rest 1. Heaven is pure and earth is turbid; heaven moves and earth is at rest. The masculine is pure and the feminine is turbid; the masculine moves and the feminine is still 2. The radical (Purity) descended, and the (turbid) issue flowed abroad; and thus all things were produced 1.
The pure is the source of the turbid, and motion is the foundation of rest.
If man could always be pure and still, heaven and earth would both revert (to non-existence) 3.
p. 251
3. Now the spirit of man loves Purity, but his mind 1 disturbs it. The mind of man loves stillness, but his desires draw it away 1. If he could always send his desires away, his mind would of itself become still. Let his mind be made clean, and his spirit will of itself become pure.
As a matter of course the six desires 2 will not arise, and the three poisons 3 will be taken away and disappear.
4. The reason why men are not able to attain to this, is because their minds have not been cleansed, and their desires have not been sent away.
p. 252
If one is able to send the desires away, when he then looks in at his mind, it is no longer his; when he looks out at his body, it is no longer his; and when he looks farther off at external things, they are things which he has nothing to do with.
When he understands these three things, there will appear to him only vacancy. This contemplation of vacancy will awaken the idea of vacuity. Without such vacuity there is no vacancy.
The idea of vacuous space having vanished, that of nothingness itself also disappears; and when the idea of nothingness has disappeared, there ensues serenely the condition of constant stillness. 1
5. In that condition of rest independently of place how can any desire arise? And when no desire any longer arises, there is the True stillness and rest.
That True (stillness) becomes (a) constant quality, and responds to external things (without error); yea, that True and Constant quality holds possession of the nature.
In such constant response and constant stillness there is the constant Purity and Rest.
He who has this absolute Purity enters gradually into the (inspiration of the) True To. And
p. 253
having entered thereinto, he is styled Possessor of the To.
Although he is styled Possessor of the To, in reality he does not think that he has become possessed of anything. It is as accomplishing the transformation of all living things, that he is styled Possessor of the To.
He who is able to understand this may transmit to others the Sacred To. 5 1
2. 1. Lo the Master said, Scholars of the highest class do not strive (for anything); those of the lowest class are fond of striving 1. Those who possess in the highest degree the attributes (of the To) do not show them; those who possess them in a low degree hold them fast (and display them) 2. Those who so hold them fast and display them are not styled (Possessors of) the To and Its attributes 2.
2. The reason why all men do not obtain the True To is because their minds are perverted. Their minds being perverted, their spirits become perturbed. Their minds being perturbed, they are attracted towards external things. Being attracted towards external things, they begin to seek for them greedily. This greedy quest leads to perplexities and annoyances; and these again result in disordered
p. 254
thoughts, which cause anxiety and trouble to both body and mind. The parties then meet with foul disgraces, flow wildly on through the phases of life and death, are liable constantly to sink in the sea of bitterness, and for ever lose the True To.
3. The True and Abiding To! They who understand it naturally obtain it. And they who come to understand. the To abide in Purity and Stillness. 1
Footnotes
247:1
.
247:2
.
248:1
or
.
248:2
.
248:3 See the Accounts of Ko in the Biographical Dictionary of Hsio Kih-han (1793), and Wang Kh's supplement to the great work of M Twan-lin, ch. 242.
249:1a 'The three regions (
)' here can hardly be the trilokya of the Buddhists, the ethical categories of desire, form, and formlessness. They are more akin to the Brahmanic bhuvanatraya, the physical or cosmological categories of bhr or earth, bhuvah or heaven, and svar or atmosphere.
249:1 The name here is Lo Kn (
). I have stated (vol. xxxix, p. 40) that, with the addition of Thi Shang, this is the common designation of Lo-dze as the Father of Toism and deifying him, and that it originated probably in the Thang dynasty. It might seem to be used simply here by Ko Hsan with the same high application; and since in his preface he refers to different 'Divine Rulers,' it may be contended that we ought to translate Lo Kn by 'Lo the Ruler.' But I am unwilling to think that the deification of Lo-dze p. 250 had taken place so early. The earliest occurrence of the combination Lo Kn which has attracted my notice is in the history of Khung Yung, a descendant of Confucius in the twentieth generation,--the same who is celebrated in the San Dze King, for his fraternal deference at the age of four, and who met with a violent death in A.d. 208. While still only a boy, wishing to obtain an interview with a representative of the Lo family, he sent in this message to him, 'My honoured predecessor and the honoured Lo, the predecessor of your Li family, equally virtuous and righteous, were friends and teachers of each other.' The epithet Kn is equally applied to Confucius and Lo-dze, and the combination Lo Kn implies no exaltation of the latter above the other.
249:2 See To Teh King, chaps. 18, 25, 53.
249:3 T. T. K., chaps. 1, 51, et al.
249:4 See Kwang-dze, Bk. II, par. 2. 'Passions,' that is, feelings, affections; as in the first of the thirty-nine Articles.
249:5 T. T. K., chaps. 1, 25, 32, 51.
249:6 T. T. K., ch. 25.
250:1 This paragraph is intended to set forth 'the production of all things;' but it does so in a way that is hardly intelligible. Comparing what is said here with the utterances in the former paragraph, To would seem to be used in two p. 251 senses; first as an Immaterial Power or Force, and next as the Material Substance, out of which all things come. Li Hs-yeh says that in the first member of par. 1 we have 'the Unlimited (or Infinite) producing the Grand (or Primal) Finite.' On the To in par. 2 he says nothing. The fact is that the subject of creation in the deepest sense of the name is too high for the human mind.
250:2 Compare T. T. K., ch. 61.
250:3 I do not understand this, but I cannot translate the Text otherwise. Mr. Balfour has:--'If a man is able to remain pure and motionless, Heaven and Earth will both at once come and dwell in him.' L explains thus:--
. Compare T. T. K., ch. 16, and especially Ho-shang Kung's title to it,--
.
251:1 Toism thus recognises in man the spirit, the mind, and the body.
251:2 'The six desires' are those which have their inlets in the eyes, cars, nostrils, the tongue, the sense of touch, and the imagination. The two last are expressed in Chinese by shn, 'the body,' and , 'the idea, or thought.'
251:3 'The three poisons' are greed, anger, and stupidity;--see the Khang-hs Thesaurus, under
.
252:1 In this paragraph we have what Mr. Wylie calls 'the subjection of the mental faculties;' and I must confess myself unable to understand what it is. It is probably another way of describing the Toist trance which we find once and again in Kwang-dze, 'when the body becomes like a withered tree, and the mind like slaked lime' (Bk. II, par. 1, et al.). But such a sublimation of the being, as the characteristic of its serene stillness and rest, is to me inconceivable.
253:5 1 This is the consummation of the state of Purity. In explaining the former sentence of the fifth member, L Hs-yeh uses the characters of T. T. K., ch. 4,
, with some variation,--
.
253:1 Compare the T. T. K., ch. 41, 1.
253:2 Compare the T. T. K., ch. 38, 1.
254:1 Our brief Classic thus concludes, and our commentator Li thus sums up his remarks on it:--'The men who understand the To do so simply by means of the Absolute Purity, and the acquiring this Absolute Purity depends entirely on the Putting away of Desire, which is the urgent practical lesson of the Treatise.'
I quoted in my introductory remarks L's account of the origin of the Classic by its reputed author Ko Hsan. I will now conclude with the words which he subjoins from 'a True Man, Zo Hsan:'--'Students of the To, who keep this Classic in their hands and croon over its contents, will get good Spirits from the ten heavens to watch over and protect their bodies, after which their spirits will be preserved by the seal of jade, and their bodies refined by the elixir of gold. Both body and spirit will become exquisitely ethereal, and be in true union with the To!'
Of this 'True Man, Zo Hsan,' I have: not been able to ascertain anything. The Divine Ruler of the eastern Hwa, referred to on p. 248, is mentioned in the work of Wang Kh (ch. 241, p. 21b), but with no definite information about him. The author says his surname was Wang, but he knows neither his name nor when he lived.
